Why “Enough” Kt/V Does Not Present “Optimum” Dialysis

Dialysis-Dependent Changes in Ventricular Repolarization
May 16, 2021 0 Comments

March 7, 2007 — The explanations that reaching “sufficient” Kt/V targets doesn’t confer optimum high quality of life to dialysis sufferers had been defined in a joint presentation by Carl Kjellstrand, MD, from Loyola College in Chicago, Illinois, and Rod Kenley, previously with Aksys in Libertyville, Illinois, on the 2007 Annual Convention on Dialysis.

Dr. Kjellstrand advised Medscape that the primary message from his discuss was: “We’re tyrannized by the Kt/V idea. We name it ‘sufficient’ when the mortality price of sufferers who’re ‘adequately’ handled is 25% (which is worse than most cancers), when principally no one is rehabilitated due to the deadening fatigue that they’ve between dialysis periods, and when one third of all dialysis sufferers ‘crash’ [have hypotension], cramp, or vomit.” He added that sufferers “very loudly” say that this isn’t a life price dwelling, as 20% of them in the end want to die moderately than proceed such a therapy, and stopping dialysis is now the second main explanation for demise in dialysis sufferers in america, following cardiovascular deaths.

Mr. Kenley defined to Medscape that Kt/V — the place Ok is the dialyzer clearance of urea, t is the dialysis time, and V is the affected person’s whole physique water — was developed by Dr. Frank Gotch and Dr. John Sargent as a method to measure the dose of dialysis once they analyzed the info from the Nationwide Cooperative Dialysis Research.

Kt/V Must be a Means, Not a Objective

Dr. Kjellstrand advised the viewers that “sufficient” is outlined as “barely passable” and requested: “Is that what we wish to give our sufferers?” He famous that in america, with the present “sufficient” dialysis goal of Kt/V of 1.2, the dialysis affected person demise price is 25%, the rehabilitation price is lower than 10%, and “each fifth affected person finds life so depressing he prefers to be lifeless.”

“The objectives we should always have for our sufferers are snug dialysis, regular blood stress, prime quality of life, and a survival that ought to rival that of transplantation, because it did that early on,” he stated.

Dr. Kjellstrand identified that within the Kidney Illness Outcomes High quality Initiative (KDOQI) pointers, 27 pages are dedicated to Kt/V, 4 pages to how to attract postdialysis samples, and solely 2 pages to high quality of life and satisfaction degree. He summarizes that “one thing went improper” and notes that the present apply of dialysis is characterised by attempting to good a way of dialysis. “One definition of lunacy is to do the identical factor again and again and anticipate one thing completely different to occur,” he noticed.

The job of the unreal kidney is to exchange the renal perform of a traditional kidney, which implies sustaining homeostasis, Dr. Kjellstrand defined. When sufferers are dialyzed 3 occasions per week they swing wildly forwards and backwards from acidosis to alkalosis, from hyperkalemia to hypokalemia, and from fluid overload to fluid contraction, however when sufferers are switched to each day dialysis the fluctuations are a lot smaller, he famous.

With the present 3-times-a-week hemodialysis, there’s a “70-hour killer wait” from Friday to Monday or from Saturday to Tuesday, and research have proven that the demise price of dialysis sufferers on Monday or Tuesday is twice that of different weekdays, he stated, including: “The very long time between dialysis is clearly very harmful, when the sufferers get sick and die.”

Optimum Dialysis Is a “Transferring Goal”

Commenting to Medscape, he noticed: “I don’t suppose there’s one easy method to describe ‘optimum dialysis.’ It is going to be a shifting goal, and the outline will change with time.” He defined that he tried to match present dialysis strategies with objectives of dialysis. He added that the aim of a man-made kidney is to exchange renal perform — that’s, to do the next jobs: keep homeostasis, catabolize bigger peptides, produce and take away hormones, secrete small molecular waste, and at last to filter small molecular waste (Kt/V). The out there strategies are hemodialysis, hemofiltration, hemodiafiltration, and adsorption, and the means are lengthy each night time, quick each day, lengthy each different night time, lengthy 3 nights per week, and three quick dialysis periods per week.

“Once I analyzed the roles to be achieved, my conclusion was that 3-times-a-week hemodialysis is by far the worst and must be changed with each day hemodialysis, and the strategy that greatest solved all the roles needed was nightly lengthy hemodiafiltration. That’s the solely methodology that would take away sufficient beta-2 microglobulin and thus stop the serous arthropathy that’s now an inevitable complication in longtime survivors of dialysis.”

Maintaining Ok, t, and V Inside Sure Relative Ranges

Mr. Kenley defined to the viewers that “Kt/V is barely a measure of sufficient dialysis if Ok, t and V are held in particular ranges relative to one another whereas reaching the KDOQI-stipulated worth.” He clarified that when Ok is excessive relative to t and V, the next issues happen: lowered fistula use, lowered fistula survival, elevated again filtration, and a disproportionate elimination of urea relative to elimination of sodium, phosphorus, and different essential molecules. When t is low relative to Ok and V, blood-pressure management worsens, intradialytic hypotension will increase, and mortality will increase. Lastly, when V is low relative to Ok and t, mortality will increase.

He commented to Medscape: “The essence of my discuss was to indicate why growing Ok, significantly by growing blood-flow price and reducing t, finally ends up creating a variety of issues . . . Ok and t must be in a comparatively slim vary relative to one another. . . . [Also,] we now have found in different scientific trials {that a} low V relative to a better Kt provides you the appropriate quantity if you do the calculations however will be an indicator of malnutrition and sufferers undereating as a result of they’re getting insufficient dialysis; or they need a shorter therapy time so they need their physique weight to be decrease, so that they cease consuming.”

Standards for Optimum Dialysis

He introduced the viewers along with his 16 standards for optimum dialysis:

  1. Normalized blood stress with minimal antihypertensive medicines.

  2. Normalized calcium-phosphate product with neither phosphate binders nor phosphate dietary supplements.

  3. An absence of intradialytic signs equivalent to hypotension, cramps, and nausea.

  4. An absence of interdialytic signs.

  5. No interference with capability to carry a job.

  6. Protein urge for food underneath the affected person’s free will.

  7. Neither alkalotic nor acidotic.

  8. No proof of left ventricular hypertrophy.

  9. Hematocrit within the 35-to-38 vary with using no less than 50% or much less of right now’s common erythropoietin dose.

  10. No dialysis-related or access-related hospitalizations.

  11. Regular triglyceride degree.

  12. No proof of amyloidosis.

  13. The longest preservation of residual kidney perform.

  14. Life expectancy roughly that of living-related-donor transplants.

  15. Irritation close to regular.

  16. World price to deal with equal to lower than $45,000 per affected person per 12 months.

“Kt/V addresses only one of those 16 standards, the extent to which you’re eradicating nitrogen,” and subsequently it doesn’t measure optimum dialysis, he concluded.

Mr. Kenley based Aksys — producer of the PHD System, a private hemodialysis system for each day dwelling hemodialysis — in 1991 after which left and rejoined the corporate in 2004 as senior vice chairman of the superior product growth group. Dr. Kjellstrand was vice chairman, medical affairs, at Aksys from 1997 till retiring in April 2006. Aksys not too long ago ceased operations.

2007 Annual Convention on Dialysis; February 18–20, 2007

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *